For over two decades, Lucy's on the Square has been delighting taste buds with our homemade pies, baked fresh in-house since 2004. Using time-honored recipes and the finest ingredients, we've earned a reputation for serving the best pies in town. From everyday indulgences to show-stopping desserts for parties and events, and especially during the Thanksgiving season, our pies have been a centerpiece of celebrations for years. Come experience the warmth and comfort of a truly homemade pie at Lucy's – you'll taste the difference!

​

     Our selection varies daily, so give us a call to find out what's baking! Curious about our most popular pies? Check out the list below!​